We've Moved!
-
Please visit us at ACPL's new kids' blog, *One Book, Two Books, Old Books,
New Books*.
Find our latest Mock Sibert nominees by selecting "Mock Sibert" in ...
12 years ago
This blog is brought to you by the Children's Services department of the Allen County Public Library in Fort Wayne, Indiana. If you have something to say about a title on this blog, just add your comments to the blog post for that title. You can add your own title to the discussion by emailing the title and your comments to Mary Voors at mvoors@acpl.info. We look forward to a GREAT year of discussion!
7 comments:
Wow...first comment!
I thought this was a very solid book. I enjoyed Happenstance and Umber, as well as their cast of supporting characters. It was slightly predictable towards the end, but I appreciate Catanese's open end to the book...it leads quite nicely into a sequel that I would read. Towards the beginning, I saw glimpses of similarities to Graceling, which was a book I thoroughly enjoyed. It ended up taking a completely different road, which I was glad for. I think upper elementary kids will enjoy this book, as well as possibly learn a lesson or two. I commend Catanese on tackling real issues throughout this fantasy book. This one definitely makes my short list at the moment!
LOVED this story - especially the unexpected combination of genres that set it apart from other fantasies. It combined exciting action with thought-provoking insights. Characters were great fun, especially Umber and the too-truthful Oates. Super creepy at times, and the author knows how to paint pictures with words. The end was satisfying enough but really looking forward to the sequel!
I agree that this is a solid sequel opener, not a stand-alone book. I was disappointed with how the author allowed the reader to be with Hap the entire time, knowing his thoughts and emotions and experiences -- except for that key bit of information near the end. You know what I mean, the little big help that Sophie called out, that I thought Hap didn't hear until I learned that yes, he did it hear and it was key to the entire outcome of the book. The reader wasn't privy to *that* info so the story would have more suspense, I guess. This reader simply felt left behind in a critical part of the action and character development of the story.
I should have said "series opener" instead of "sequel opener," but you all probably knew what I meant. :)
Great story overall, some disappointments at the end -- I agree with Teresa, I was somewhat confused at times. However, I would definitely recommend this to young readers looking for a new fantasy series.
I liked this series opener and look forward to future installments. I sure hope it is not as drawn out as Wheel of Time! :-)
I really enjoyed the book, and look forward to future installments. I am very glad to know about this book and will recommend it widely; but don't think it stands alone.
Post a Comment