We've Moved!
-
Please visit us at ACPL's new kids' blog, *One Book, Two Books, Old Books,
New Books*.
Find our latest Mock Sibert nominees by selecting "Mock Sibert" in ...
12 years ago
This blog is brought to you by the Children's Services department of the Allen County Public Library in Fort Wayne, Indiana. If you have something to say about a title on this blog, just add your comments to the blog post for that title. You can add your own title to the discussion by emailing the title and your comments to Mary Voors at mvoors@acpl.info. We look forward to a GREAT year of discussion!
9 comments:
Wow I can’t believe I am the first to comment here.
I have read lots of books and so far this is my favorite contender for the Newbery.
Calpurnia is so likable as a creative, smart girl. She's not a tom boy but not really a prim girl either, just a nice mix in the middle.
I loved the Darwin quotes at the beginning of each chapter that really led into the rest of the chapter. An excellent first book, with a great setting. Original in story and not at all predictable.
Loved it.
Yep, little Calpurnia and her curmudgeon grandfather are favored contenders. At least that is my highly evolved opinion.
Agreed. The best one that I've read this year. Great characters (though I couldn't keep the brothers straight. With 6 of them, who could?), a setting you could live in and an interesting plot.
I thought this was a good book, but not great in my eyes. I felt that I spent the majority of the book waiting for something to happen. Calpurnia was an interesting main character with her own issues, but nothing stood out to me to make this a page-turner. I was left wanting more...
I agree with Jill. I enjoyed this book, but I thought it was easy to put down and pick up again. I thought the ideas were compelling as was the story, but it didn't have that extra bit of POW to push it over the top.
I very much enjoyed this one and been recommending it to others. If you like this one, you might also like "A Girl of the Limberlost".
I fell in love with Calpurnia Tate. I am glad that not all of her issues were resolved at the end of the book!
I suppose this book doesn't have a plotline like some others I've read, but the day-to-day grind of the Tate family gave surprising depth to weighty subjects like gender, race, wealth, and equity. While not necessarily what I'd think of as a page-turner, I was gratified to really see Callie's evolution as the story unfolded. It was witty and wry and a delightful romp as well as a real commentary on the prospects of a Southern Woman in the early 1900s.
A fine piece of historical fiction, introducing the reader to the pre-woman's rights era as well as to a good bit of natural history. It almost has the feel of a journal as it chronicles a period in the protagonists life, capturing her family life and as well as her difficulty conforming to the role society has ascribed to young women.
A fabulous book to enrich history and science curriculum, as well as an all-around good read.
This is one of my top five books of the year. Jacqueline Kelly writes an amazing first book with a very likable character, Callie Vee.
Post a Comment